HomeMy WebLinkAbout04/15/1997 Regular Council Meeting Minutes%i kR'~\' ~. 'I'OVVN ("i()t'N( Il,
Mq{ll. I$, I0~?
PLACE AND DATE
Marana Town Hall, April 15, 1997
CALL TO ORDER
By Mayor Ed Honea at 7:02 P.M.
II. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Led By Mayor Honea
III. INVOCATION
A moment of silence was observed
IV. ROLL CALL
Vo
COUNCIL
Ed Honea
Sharon Price
Tom Clark
Ora Ham
Herb Kai
Sherry Millner
Bobby Sutton, Jr.
Mayor
Vice Mayor
Councilman
Councilwoman
Councilman
Councilwoman
Councilman, excused
STAFF
Hurvie Davis
Kelly Schawb
Sandy Groseclose
Dave Atler
Joel Shapiro
Jane Johnson
Jocelyn Entz
Roy Cuaron
Doug Maples
Town Manager
Town Attorneys Office
Town Clerk
Town Engineer
Principal Planner
Human Resource Director
Assistant to Town Manager
Finance Director
Chief Building Official
18 Members of the Public
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
A motion was made by Ora Ham, seconded by Sharon Price and carried unanimously
to accept the agenda as written.
VI. ACCEPTANCE OF MINUTES
A motion was made by Ora Harn, seconded by Sharon Price and carried unanimously
to approve the minutes of April 1, 1997.
VII. CALL TO THE PUBLIC/ANNOUNCEMENTS
Don Hawkins, 11619 W. Grier, Marana: He is representing the Private Industry
Council of Pima County which oversees the Job Traiuing Partnership Act for the County.
VIII.
IX.
MAIIANA '1'()~'~ X C()I 'N( Il.
XPRII, IS. 1907
He passed out information for Council to study. He requested to be put on Council's
next agenda for possible funding for the summer youth program -- for the youth of
Marana. He advised the information was basically self explanatory with regard to the
JTPA. He commented the JTPA is asking the Town of Marana to come up with $14,000
for youth in summer program for the I 1 - 13 year age group.
Bill Schisler, 12561 N. White Ave., Marana: He spoke about the Marana Sign Code.
He wanted to commend the people who ran in the last election, the winners and the
losers both -- the signs were taken care of quickly. His complaint was with Budget
Auto, there are many American flags and other flags along with balloons around their
place and cars are parked, he's sure, beyond their property to advertise. He commented
the Marana Sign Code allows people to fly the American flag, the State flag and a
company logo flag -- but that's it. He would like for someone to check into that.
STAFF REPORTS
GENERAL ORDER OF BUSINESS
A. Consent
Resolution No. 97-31 - Cancellation Of Intergovernmental Agreement
Between Pima County and the Town of Marana for Use, Maintenance, and
Managing the Marana Public Pool
Resolution No. 97-20 - Disposition of Right - of- Way Landscaping on
Silverbeli Road and Coachline Boulevard
Ordinance No. 97.09- Amending the Marana Town Code by Adding a
Provision Which Requires Circulators of Referenda and Initiative Petitions
Concerning Local Matters to be Residents of the Town of Marana
Resolution No. 97-32 - Request by Marana Police Department for
Submission of Projects for Consideration in Arizona's 1998 Highway Safety
Plan
Resolution No. 97-28 - Amending the Intergovernmental Agreement (IGA)
with Northwest Fire District to Modify the Fee Agreement
Resolution No. 97-30 - Amending Section 3.3 of the Town of Marana Home
Investment Partnership Program (HOME) Regulations
Ora Harn moved to take items 3 and 4 off of the Consent Agenda. That item 3 could be
put on a future agenda item rather than being discussed today to give more time to
review. That item 4 be discussed as the t~rst order of business after the consent ageoda.
A ]notion was made by Ora Harn, seconded by Tom Clark and carried unanimously to
approve consent agenda items 1, 2, 5, 6 and 7.
2
Resolution No. 97-26 - Request for Approval of a Liquor License Transfer
for Circle K Stores, Inc., 13961 N. Sandario Road, Marana, Arizona
Hurvie Davis: This is a request for approval of a liquor license transfer for the Circle K
Store located at 13961 N. Sandario Road. The lype of liquor license is #9 - for a liquor
store. This is in compliance and a background check was made by the Police
Department. Staffrecommends approval of a transfer.
Ora Harn: I am kind of unfamiliar with thc license numbers, like #9, so I'm not sure
what we're talking about with a//9 license. Can someone tell me what it entitles the
Circle K to sell?
Hurvie Davis: I'm not sure what a #9 means, maybe the Town Clerk knows or the
applicant is here to speak to that issue.
Sandy Groseclose: Doesn't believe the applicant is present.
Ora Harn: Advised she received numerous calls regarding the transfer to a #9 liquor
license in which would entitle the Circle K to sell liquor other than the beer and wine
they now can sell. This is a concern.
Kelly Schwab: I just wanted to reaffirm that a #9 license allows for beer, wine and hard
liquor to be sold. She advised she believes the Circle K already has that license, this is a
request to transfer ownership of the license.
Ora Ham: l would like to speak against this item, until I am sure what this is all about
because I don't think that's a good thing for us to approve. She spoke strongly against
this issue.
A motion was made by Ora Harn and seconded by Herb Kai not to approve the transfer
of the #9 liquor license.
Tom Clark: Asked if any Circle K sells hard liquor, other than beer and wine.
Kelly Schwab: Advised she believes the Circle K already has a #9 license which allows
them to sell hard liquor.
Vice Mayor Price: Advised since the applicant was not in the audience, shouldn't this
item be placed continued rather than just turning it down.
Ora Harn advised she would drop her original motion if the second would drop his
second. A motion was made by Ora Ham, seconded by Herb Kal and unanimously
carried to have this item continued to a future agenda item.
Harvie Davis: We have an employee to be introduced to Council, this was not done at
the start -- is it possible to do that now?
MX'Rll, 15, 104t)7
Mayor Honea: Please do.
Dave Atler: ] have a staff member that is taking Harvey Gills place, John Alexander.
He brings roughly 15 years experience with him. He is a licensed surveyor and licensed
engineer in Arizona, California and New Mexico. He has a Bachelors and Masters
Degree in Civii Engineering.
B. Resolution No. 97-29; Continental Ranch Active Adult Center - Review and
Action on a Final Plat Application for a 141 Lot Single Family Residential
Subdivision on Approximately 35.9 Acres Located at the Northwest Corner of
Coachline Boulevard and Twin Peaks Road in a Portion of the East 1/2 of Section
20 and the West 1/2 of Section 21, Township 12 South, Range 12 East, Property
Owner/Application is Del Webb's Coventry Homes of Tucson, 1565 East Rancho
Vistoso Boulevard, Tucson, Arizona 85737
Hurvie Davis: This is a request for approval of a final plat located at Continental
Ranch, the applicant is Del Webb Coventry Homes of Tucson. Staff recommends for
approval. He advised the applicant is here if there are any questions.
A motion was made by Vice Mayor Sharon Price, seconded by Tom Clark and carried
unanimously to approve Resolution No. 97-29, pursuant to staffs recommendations.
C. Ordinance No. 97.10; Oldfather/Joyce Lane Annexation - Consideration
and Approval of an Annexation of Property 3.4 Acres and the Resulting Transition
of County Zoning to Marana Zoning on Property Located North of the Present
Town Limits, Adjacent to the Southeast 1/4 of Section 31, Section 31, Township 12
South, Range 13 East, Gila and Salt River Base & Meridian, Pilna County, Arizona
Hurvie Davis: This is an annexation of approximately 3.4 acres located at Oldfather and
Ina, behind the Desert Fitness complex. This was an annexation we had on the books
basically covering an entire block. After speaking with several of the residents -- of
whom didn't really want to come into the Town -- we redrew the district boundaries to
include Ms Oldfather's property. Staff recommends annexation.
A motion was made by Ora Ham, seconded by Tom Clark and carried unanimously to
approve Ordinance No. 97.10.
D. Southern Arizona Water Rights Settlement Act Effluent Utilization Study -
Prepared by the United States Bureau of Reclamation and the Pima County
Wastewater Management Department
Hurvie Davis: We originally identified this as a public hearing, not an official public
hearing in that we would have a rezoning and we would advertise the certain
requirements for a public hearing. We have this listed as a public hearing on the blue
sheet. This is a water issue that is very complex. This issue was turned over to Mr.
Holub for explanation.
4
'N, IINI'TI.'..~ 01.' I,tl.'.(,;I.'l, 'k.R COl 'NCII, '%IF]..TIN(;
%1XR.%.% '~ 'I'()N,¥N COl N(II,
.Mq~ll, I$, 1907
Hugh Holub, 177 N. Church: We have Eric Holler from the US Bureau of Reclamation
here who will do most of the presentation. Just as a brief introduction, for years the
Tohono O'Odham Tribe has been suing the City of Tucson mining complex and the
agricultural interest in the basin, claming that the ground water pumping around the
Reservation over by the San Xavier Mission has infringed on the Indians Water Rights.
Rather than litigate that, the mines, the farms and Tucson entered into a settlement
agreement with the Tribe. Pan of that settlement agreement, the City of Tucson gave up
rights to 28,200 acre feet of effluent per anum. The Legislation that approved that
settlement made it very clear that the effluent was not to be delivered to the Indians.
There is no funding for utilization of that effluent as a direct delivery. Pima County of
course has been concerned about the effluent not being used. That effluents discharge
into the river flows down to Marana, so a study was done to look at the opportunity at
what can be done with that.
Eric Holler, US Bureau of Reclamation, 4257 W. Ina Rd.: I understand that Pima
County made a presentation before Council late last year on this SAWRSA Effluent
Utilization Study. The study looked at ways to beneficially use this SAWRSA effluent
so we can gain value for it. The study is quite dated, it's over three years old. What was
done with the study and one of the biggest benefits to the study was we brought out an
understanding of what this SAWRSA effluent meant. What it meant to the Tohono
O'Odham and raised the consciousness of Tohono O'Odham and the community in
general as far as how the effluent would play out in the over all water management
scheme in utilizing CAP water. The Tohono O'Odham biggest concern was they didn't
want water tread in some crude and then pumped out from under the Reservation. The
Secretary of Interior is responsible for finding value for this effluent in order to
implement SAWRSA. Reclamation has been delegated the authority to try and find
ways to use this effluent and so that was the reason for the study. When the needs and so
forth were brought up by Tohono O'Odham, the lnterior basically decided they weren't
going to necessarily listen to the Tohono O'Odham, because they have no rights under
this settlement act in regards to the effluent. Reclamation convinced the Interior it's in
all of our best interests to address these concerns in as much as possible because the
reason for the SAWRSA lawsuit in the first place was due to ground water pumping
violations against the Tohono O'Odham. He passed out some information -- a recap of
where Reclamation has gone, including a workshop that Reclamation put on three weeks
ago. He gave a brief description of what each page contained.
Herb Kai: It seems like these studies have just gone on and on. Don't you think it's
more prudent to really get into an active plan mode? It seems like there's 7 studies that
have been done in this packet already.
Eric Holler: Most of the comments at the workshop were reflected what you just said,
we've done enough study, it's time to plan some physical things to do with the effluent.
Herb Kai: Do you have funding available now for this plan?
Eric Holler: We have funds to do the study.
5
'MI.¥1."H.SN Oi.' Ri.:~,;'l, I,AI,~ COl "N('II, MEI.71:JN(;-
MAI,L~,~. 4, 'l'()x,,~ ,~ ( :O[ 'N('i [,
x.I)Ri[, i~, 1097
Herb Kal: Marana residents are concerned, we need to get that effluent out of the river.
Hurvie Davis: Advised that Cathy Chavez with Pima County Wastewater Department is
here also. He advised item H relates to this issue.
Cathy Chavez, Pima County Wastewater Department: We have worked on this
study and talked with you a little bit on it last year. We agree with Councilman Kal,
there have been many studies done on the effluent. The County would like to see some
design and construction money committed to do some projects to put the effluent
directly to use.
Eric Holler: 1 would like to point out that when the first study was done, really nobody
had taken the responsibility for this effluent -- it was just out there. I've been working
with the Bureau in Santa Cruz County where they're using similar authority as here.
We've been able to get grant money to proceed on a constructed wet land project to start
reusing effluent down there. They assisted Nogales in writing a grant request to the
State Water Protection Fund. The Bureau's collaboration has been very beneficial in
getting everybody together and getting action type activities. There are 2 things we need
to do, we need to endorsee the concept of the study, which is the Resolution item and
second we've got to do a little lobbying behind the scenes to Congress because they need
some appropriations to go forward. Federal agencies are prohibited by law to lobby in
Congress.
No action taken.
E. Lower Santa Cruz River Replenishment Proiect/Bank Protection
Hurvie Davis: These items are all tied in with item H. It's an issue that Mr. Atler has
been dealing with and we have Leo Smith with Pima County to give us an update on the
Santa Cruz Bank Protection as well information on the replenishment project.
Dave Atler: We got a permit request from Pima County for a flood plain use permit for
them to construct the recharge basins for replenishment project within the Santa Cruz
River. This would be upstream, south of Honea Heights. At that time Mr. Davis, Mr.
Holub, Mr. Byron Howard and myself got together with others to talk about what impact
this may have and how it related to the Town -~ strictly speaking how it was linked to the
lower Santa Cruz Levee project and what would timing be. My concern was if there was
going to be this loss of material in the river then we may have some damage done on
adjacent properties.
Leo Smith, Division Manager for Flood Control Dist., Pima County: Briefly talked
about the high plains project his department is working on with the Bureau of
Reclamation. He stated at first they believed the levee project would be done very soon.
Their timetrack on starting that was based on their department being able to acquire state
land. State land department indicated about a year ago that they anticipated they would
be able to begin the process of getting those lands to auction in around the beginning of
this year. At the beginning of this year, they informed Mr. Smith that the date is
6
MI.M"I'ES OF I~II.'.¢;I'I.AR ('OI'N( II. MEI.:TIN(;
M 'xl~,XN ~ 'I'OXVN COI,N(:II.
'~PRII. I$, 1097
probably closer to September. That's hindered their ability to go out and build because
they don't have the land. He advised at today's Board of Supervisors meeting; they
passed 4 - 0 the Truth and Bonding Ordinance, which says that if the bonds pass on May
20, then the Department is obligated to go do the projects that were stated in the bond
package and do them on the dates that were stated on that package. The anticipated time
period of the levee construction is about an 18 month period. It actually falls in 3 budget
years. It was asked, how do we go about paying for everything? He advised that
through the budget years and by Federal aid. He commented that the Water Banking
Authority has water that it's willing to put in the ground if somebody has a facility to put
it in the ground. Likewise a year ago, we hadn't really thought of anyone helping us
construct the replenishing basin, CAWCD now does have demonstration money that they
are willing to spend on some of these projects.
Mayor Itonea: Commented he's been told several times a bank protection was going to
be built and it hasn't yet. He has some reservations as to what the county says they're
going to do. He asked the building is going to be done over 3 fiscal years?
Leo Smith: That's correct.
Mayor Honea: You want to build the replenishment project across from Honea Heights
neighborhood prior to putting the levee up to protect them if there were a problem?
Leo Smith: I think that's correct, the initial phase of the replenishment basin would be
the 4 basins below Honea Heights. It would have to be something greater than a 25 year
event in order to actually flow into the basins as they're designed right now. There was
a sediment transport that was run on the initial '88 design concept report for the levee
alignment in here. It didn't show a problem with the river flowing with the levee
alignment the way it was with the low flow channel. Now with the Iow flow channel not
in there, we need to go back and anylize that again. That's being done.
Mayor Honea: You are aware that the area where you want to build the replenishment
area has flooded several times?
Leo Smith: Yes.
Mayor Honea: Advised it flooded in 1979, 1983 and 1993. It flooded 3 times, fairly
severely in the last 18 years. He commented his concern is if the project is built prior to
the levee getting to the Honea Heights area; and there is one of these 25 year floods --
the people that live in the Honea Heights community may be endangered. Another
problem we have here, when you're talking about 25 year flow, is the City of Tucson and
Pima County have built so many storm sewers and paved so many streets that the water
gets here more quickly and at a higher volume. One of the worse problems on the Santa
Cruz River, is right exactly where you want to build that project. That thing overflows
there almost every time you get a major flood.
Leo Smith: Maybe to clear up what they are -- around basin 4 there will be a small
protective berm to keep the 25 year event out a bit only because it's getting into the other
7
t-T.'.x d-,r'o i:"s ci . .........
%I.'q.R ~,%'.,$. 'I'OXN. X COl 'X('II,
.Xlq{ll. 15, 1997
Herb Kai: Stated he has the same concerns as Mayor Honea. lfthe 4 cells are open for
the recharge basin, don't you think the construction of the dike on the north side would
coincide instead of a gap somewhere?
Leo Smith: Staff has looked at the idea of taking that material out and laying it back
where the fill material would have to go in the event the soil cement started to get
constructed. There are 2 main components involved in the building of the levee. The fill
material is one and the soil cement's the other one. We could in excavating the first 4 of
those, we've talked about a couple different areas where we could place the material.
Ora Harn: Stated it's quite understandable that the property owners who have been
approached to give property for the bank protection, want some assurances for that land.
None of us have really been able to feel comfortable that Pima County will do what they
say they will.
Mayor Honea: Advised Mr. Smith that Council is not trying to beat him up -- it's just
that Council is frustrated because they have been told by the County several times that a
bank protection will be built. He is concerned about the Honea Heights neighborhood.
He feels the bank protection needs to be built prior to the other stuff:
Leo Smith: Advised Council that the Flood Control District has wanted to build this
levee for a long time, sometimes it's the Supervisors that make the final decisions. A
floodplain use permit has not been issued and without that permit, work cannot be done.
He commented there a number IGA's that need to be worked out. The IGA's better
define what's happening with the project. He advised that once the bond issues pass, if
they pass -- there should be things in place that will make Council feel more comfortable
about what is being done.
Hurvie Davis: lfthe bond issue does not pass, do you know if the County or the district
has funding available to be utilized to reach the total of $15,500,000 to accomplish it?
Leo Smith: There are 2 mechanism that were looked at earlier. One was some kind of
staged construction of the levee -- it would take 5 budget years to do it. The other issue
was to look at some municipal property corporation bonds, that again has to go to the
vote of the Board. There is always the option that's available to the Board of Directors
of the Flood Control District who are the Board of Supervisors. They could raise the
levee amount and actually bring in more secondary tax money for a period of time.
Hurvie Davis: The water that would be utilized is CAP water.'?
Leo Smith: In a recharge, that's correct.
Hurvie Davis: It certainly behooves all of us throughout the state of Arizona to do
something with that CAP water. As you know California and Nevada would like to get
Tucson's share of the CAP. 1 sense the concerns of the Council that, while we want to
do something to utilize the CAP water, we want bank protection to protect the lives and
MI.'SU'I'I.~S ¢)1.' RI.~¢;I. I..%R ("OUN('II. AIEI.'.'I'I~(;
MAI~tA~;A '1'O~3, ~ COI'N('II.
,'~PI~II. 15, 199,'7.
safety of the people in the neighborhoods. How can we get the bank protection and get
the recharge at the same time? It's a very difficult issue.
Ora Harn: I also share Mayor's concerns. 1 would like to ask, can Pima County build
this recharge project in the Town of Marana without the permission of Marana?
Hugh Holub: Advised the State Statute that authorized County Flood Control Districts
to do replenishment recharge projects says twice in the same sentence that they cannot
do a project like this without it having a direct flood control benefit. I have talked with
the County and advised them they can't build the project without the flood control
benefit and their word isn't going to get it, because for 15 years Marana has been waiting
for something to happen. Mr. Smith came up with 5 agreements to be looked at.
Ora Itarn: 1 think l made myself very clear that we don't trust them. I want the best
attorneys in Arizona to put the IGA's together. That's the only way I will vote yes on
this issue.
Hurvie Davis: Mr. Holub has drafted and IGA that currently the staff in Town is
reviewing. Upon such review and comment back to Mr. Holub which includes the
general Council for the Town as well, we will forward that draft IGA to Pima County. If
we reach agreement in the IGA that the recharge project and the basins do not proceed
until the bank protection proceeds. The bank protection in itself is over a 3 year period
of time. I believe the County really wants to move much sooner than that. If they start
the bank protection, is that an acceptable indication that we're going to get the bank
protection all the way down so we'll approve the recharge basin and give them the
permit and they move forward on that? I believe 1 heard Mr. Smith state earlier that they
were going to use materials out of the basins for the entire levee project.
Leo Smith: There are portions of the actual levee project in the beginning that because
of where they land. I can't tell you exactly how far it goes, when I say the project is
going to overlap 3 budget years, we envision it right now to be an 18 month process. It
begins in FY '97-98 for the entire '98-99 year and the tail end will be in the beginning of
the '99-2000 year. In that time, the soil cement goes rapidly. I would envision that
within a years period we could put all the soil cement in and start the backfilling
operation and then after that come in with the safety railing -- there are other issues that
come in on the bank protection.
Hurvie Davis: Mr. Huckleberry indicated to me that in conversation that excavation of
the basin would not in any way further jeopardize the safety of the Honea Heights
neighborhood, has that analysis been done and provided to Mr. Atler?
Leo Smith: Yes, we have an analysis from an engineering consultant on that issue. I
have not looked at it yet.
Hurvie Davis: There seems to be some misunderstanding, but in Mr. Huckleberry's
letter he said the bank protection would extend from Continental Ranch which I assume
is from the end of the Continental Ranch Bank Protection, from that point down stream.
10
Earlier this evening you had indicated from Avra Valley Road downstream, there won't
be a gap in there will there?
Leo Smith: No. I think it's easier to explain the project as going from Avra Valley
Road to Sanders Road because those are 2 places on the map that people can see. But in
fact it will tie in to the existing bank protection just south of the Avra Valley Bridge.
There will be a new bridge built there and then the bank protection will be brought up to
protect the bridge and then from the bridge it will come on forward.
Hugh Holub: Commented this whole discussion brings up a crucial point as to why
there is a need for IGA's. He advised Council they are going to have to exercise their
sovern control over these kinds of projects.
Leo Smith: It did become apparent to the Flood Control District Staff that there were
things being done that we were not necessarily advising everybody in Marana about. So
we've set about changing that direction so at least Dave, Hurvie and Hugh are in the
development process of what we're doing here.
Out of Session at 8:30 P.M.
Back in Session at 8:40P.M.
Mayor Itonea: Advised item H will be handled and then will go back to items F and G.
H. Resolution No. 97-33 - Endorsement for Creating a Regional Effluent
Planning Task Force and Participation in the Development of a Regional Effluent
Utilization Plan
Hurvie Davis: This was addressed earlier by Mr. Holub and Mr. Holler. Staff
recommends approval of this resolution and that Council designates a representative to
the Task Force. That Mayor and Council contact the congressional delegation perhaps
with a letter attached to the Resolution if passed, to encourage funding support for the
Bureau of Reclamation to participate in a regional effort.
Herb Kal: Local participation would be expected to contribute 50% of the cost of such
study, mostly through in kind contribution -- is that just paying for the cost of the study
or is this paying for the cost of the project. How do we define in kind?
Hugh Holub: Both of them. The study; you have to have participation and then when
we get to a project phase, again there are matching contribution requirements. One of
the things that's going to be pursued with Congress is seeing if some of these projects
cau be authorized without a local matching share. But ordinarily there is a local
matching share required when you get a Federal Grant. Then worked out on a Grant to
Grant basis, how much of that would be in kind work that the Town can do with Town
Start; how much of it has to be dollars.
MINI "1'1'~% OI.' I,tl.~(;I I,.S,R COl :NC 'Il, MEI,71'IN¢;
%IAI~t,~NA 'I'O~,¥N COl
~PRII. I~, 1997
Herb Kal: I guess there's going to be some fresh water exchanges and recovery and 1
think the Town should be involved in where these fresh water wells will be getting water
back to the Bureau or the Indians That's something we need to look at very carefully.
Hugh Holub: We're trying to get through a network of 1GA's, absolute control over
recovery wells within the Town.
Ora Harm ls the effluent we're talking about, the portion that belongs to the Bureau?
Hugh Holub: No, the Secretary has 28,000 feet of effluent but there's another
considerable chunk of effluent that's continuing to be dumped in the river by Tucson
without being utilized. We're going to have some effluent -- the goal is to look at all of
the effluent, not just the Secretary's.
Dave Atler: There's roughly 61,000 acre feet per year that is produced of effluent. The
Secretary gets 28,200 acre feet and 1 believe there's been less than 10,000 acre feet per
year used around the region o golf courses and agricultural uses. There's quite a bit left
that's coming down the river.
A motion was made by Herb Kal, seconded by Tom Clark and carried unanimously to
approve Resolution 97-33.
F. Sub-Regional Transportation Study
Hurvie Davis: This issue has been before you. Previously with status reports.
Dave Atler: We approached Mr. Luick to do a subregional transportation study for us.
The cover for the book shows you what the study area was. This could act as our core
transportation study that we could attach as new development areas come in.
Mr. Luick: Mr, Luick spoke briefly on areas that need to be worked on. He commented
on the difference between his study and that of the PAG. His study is looking at a 30 to
35 year time period whereas the study done by PAG is looking at a 20 year time period.
He advised the study area currently shows about 4,000 homes and his study envisions a
build out increase to about 26,000 homes. He advised a good indication that you have
emerging transportation problems is when intersections start not to work well anymore.
He spoke briefly on the study and a series of recommendations -- which can be found
starting on page 37. He advised the study is lengthy, however he tried to word it so it
would be easy to understand. He believes funding will be the most problematic area. He
stated he is finished with the study and hopes the Town will continue to monitor what is
happening with traffic and land use in the area.
Dave Atler: Some of the main issues that Mr. Luick brought out this evening, have been
timing and funding. The purpose of the graph was actually to target when we had to be
in the ground, so we can start programming for the various things thal we had to do up
until we get the construction done. The other issue associated with that was that Mr.
Davis convinced the Regional Council to ask ADOT to include in their 5 year
12
MI~I"I'E~ {il.' RI.'.GI I.,~1{ ¢ 'O{'~CII,
MAR~N ~'IO~3, N COVN('II.
~,PRII. 15, Iq~)7
transportation program a scoping phase for the Linda Vista/Twin Peak interchange.
Council Member Ham will be talking with the group this week.
Ora Harn: Asked if it would be possible to have some sort of visual ready for Friday.
She advised if we did something like that, maybe they'd have more of a concept of us
not just wanting something else but showing that it is good planning for the whole
northwest side.
Hurvie Davis: I think it would be helpful if we had something, just a map or an aerial
photograph or something of that nature. That's is a good idea and to point out the fact
that it's almost 4 miles between the Cortaro interchange and the Avra Valley interchange
and obviously Orange Grove, Ina and Cortaro -- those 3 interchanges could not handle
the traffic both on the east and west side of the interstate.
Ora Ham: I would like you to do one thing for me though on that visual, be sure to put
in the Mountain View High School, if you could and Tortolita Jr. High to show that
actually those 2 schools on the east side of the freeway are kind of bound in and the only
routes they could use is Thornydale and Cortaro Road. They have constraints on how
they can get in and out. This would actually relieve that kind of constraints.
Dave Atler: Another issue that can be raised is in regards to safety and agrade crossing
of the railroad. The school buses that you're talking about are having to cross that area.
ADOT ignored issues such as outside influences on the capacity. They looked
specifically within their right-of-way at the capacity and fanctionality of that
interchange. 1 believe Mr. Davis mentioned recently that Union Pacific is talking about
adding another line, maybe doubling the nnmber of trains that go through there.
G. Pima Association of Governments Regional Council Meeting Agenda -
Review for discussion and Direction
Hurvie Davis: The agenda that you have before you is the agenda of the management
committee. He advised Item #11 (the Transportation Improvement Program policies)
has been removed from the agenda. He commented the TIP Subcommittee did a lot of
work, and he wasn't faulting that. He suggested it go back to the Subcommittee to see
that what is being proposed is best for us on the smaller jurisdictions. He further advised
after the PAG meeting at 8:15 there will be a joint meeting with ADOT. It will be the
first meeting in Tucson with our new representative, Ms Katy Doosenberry, who has
been active in transportation in our County for a long time.
Mayor and Council's Report
Sherry Millner: The 20th Anniversary Committee went out and had a celebration last
Saturday. We had a lot of fun -- we played golf and rode bumper boats.
Herb Kal: No report.
~3
'MINI"I'I.;~ I.II; RI:.(;I 'IAR COl 'NCIi. 'ill:.l,:Tl~(;
~.J .~ I,J.¥~,,~, 'I'()~¥N ('el 'N( '1I,
.M~'RII. I~, 1097
Ora Itarn: Wanted to advise Council the committee selecting the Assistant Town
Manager met on the 11. We have one more process to go through. We are going to do
some sight visits, to see where these people live and work. We want to make sure we
select the most qualified person. She asked if a thank you letter can be sent to Mr. Dan
McQuade for his help.
Toni Clark: No report.
Vice Mayor Sharon Price: No Report.
Mayor Honea: Council Member Sutton, Jocelyn and I were participants in the
Highlands Golf Tournament for the Chamber of Commerce. It was my very first attempt
at playing golf: I'm glad that everyone was patient with me and that the golf course was
still usable when I got through. I would encourage any of you who play golf to
participate next year~
J. Manager's Report
Hurvie Davis: I have received a report from the Arizona Department of Economic
Security with some Arizona demographics. They talked about the population from July
1990 to July 1996. 1'11 read a paragraph sentence to you: "Ore Valley was Arizona's
fastest growing incorporated place with a 221% increase, followed by Marana 172%,
Gilbert /31%, San Luis 109%, and Prescott Valley by 89%. Ore Valley's population
incidentally in 1996 was at 21,405 -- Town of Marana is 5,960 person." Just thought 1
would pass that information along to you. Most of the Water Department staffwith the
exception of Ann Meaders has moved to the Old Police Department building. I believe
the number is 616-4908 as opposed to a 682 exchange. We had some problems with the
apparent low bidder for our spring chip seal program. I believe we will be awarding the
contract to the second lowest bidder. We'll still be able to make our schedule. I've also
dealt with several employee problems over the last couple of weeks. Apparently we've
reached resolutions on those issues before they became major ones. We're still under
way for the budget preparation. We'll be working on that, we have a lot of fine tuning to
do before we can bring that budget to you. The July fourth celebration, we are having
some difficulty in getting major sponsors. More so than we've had in the past. If any of
you have anyone that wants to be a major sponsor for the fourth of July celebration we
could use some help on that.
Ora Ham: One other items that I think is important. 1 don't know if I can call Roxanne
Ziegler a Council Member yet or not, but she and I have been working on setting some
informational meetings for the bond program. We have selected May 12 at the Marana
Town Recreational Center at 7:00 and May 15 at Wade Road at the Fire Department as
Public Meetings where Pima County is going to bring out some staff and give
information about the bonding program. The bond election is May 20 and we think that
will give people time to get information about what issues will be on the bonding.
14
MINI"I'I".~ O1" RF.(;I I,AR C¢)U.NCII, MIJ'71'IN(;
MARA~ % 'I'OV~'~ COl X("II.
.~,I)RII. I$, 19~)7
X. FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS
There were Bone.
XI.
ADJOURNMENT
A motion was made by Tom Clark, seconded by Herb Kal and carried unanimously to
adjourn the meeting at 9:22 P.M.
CERTIFICATION
1 certify that the foregoing minutes are the true and correct minutes of the Regular
Council Meeting of the Marana Town Council held on April 15, 1997. I further certify
that a quorum was present.
15